Cookie Palooza 2012

Cookie Palooza 2012

The 2nd annual Cookie Palooza started Saturday night and continued through Monday; surprisingly (sadly?), I have to say it wasn't as much fun as last year.

Maybe if I had stopped Sunday after making 3 different kinds of bar cookies as well as the first batch of cheesecake cookies, well then, perhaps I'd feel differently. Instead, I'm just plain sick to death of all things sugar at this point and, in fact, couldn't bring myself to write this post last night because it was sounding way the hell too whiny even to me.

So. New day, no more sugar, and my house no longer smells like baked goods after making spicy tacos, lentils primavera, and stuffed mushrooms; lots of savory smells to cancel out the sweet, thank goodness.

Cookie Palooza 2012

3 different bar cookies

I started out by making this recipe for PB&J blondies, except I left out the "J" part. They turned out pretty well... okay, REALLY well based on the fact that my roommate inhaled 4 of the cookie bars before I could even put them away. Now, the cookie exchange at work this year doesn't have as many participants as last year so we only need to make 2 dozen of our chosen cookie/dessert. A pan of these bars slices quite nicely into 24 pieces which is the perfect amount. However, since my roommate had already eaten several of them, I knew I would need to make another batch which would also give me the chance to tweak the recipe a little more to my liking, namely, using a little less sugar and adding in some chocolate chunks. The second batch, made yesterday, turned out beautifully (even if I couldn't taste them) and I was sure to package and label them immediately as OFF LIMITS so that these can make it to work tomorrow for the exchange.

Because I was so pleased with how the first cookie bar turned out, I decided to try out another recipe for Oatmeal Scotchies that I pulled off the bag of Nestle butterscotch chips. Again, being me, I couldn't leave well enough alone and added chopped pecans to the recipe and baked them in a pan rather than as a drop cookie. (There was a note at the bottom of the recipe with instructions on how to make them a bar cookie.) Maybe it was because my pan wasn't big enough and the bars were a little too thick (in my opinion), but I wasn't terribly impressed with the way these cookies turned out. Yes, the flavor was good, but the texture left a little something to be desired. Eh. Live and learn, right? (Of course, my roommate didn't find fault with them given the number she's already eaten.)

cheesecake cookies with graham cracker crust

Next up were the cheesecake cookies. I found this recipe online from The Brown Eyed Baker after doing quite a bit of searching, and these cookies were fantastic! What I really loved about the recipe (besides the taste, of course) was how simple it was. I read many other recipes that involved rolling the dough into a log and rolling the log in the crumb of choice before refrigerating, slicing, and baking. Not only are there very few ingredients, but once the dough comes together, you roll it into golf ball sized balls (maybe a little smaller), roll them in your crumb of choice (I used graham crackers for the first batch, then crushed Oreos for the 2nd batch at my roommate's insistence), and bake.

cheesecake cookies with oreo crust

Now, I will say that I doubled the recipe because the original recipe only makes about 12 cookies, and maybe I did make them smaller than I was supposed to because I got 34 cookies out of my doubled recipe. Plus, I refrigerated the dough to let it firm up a bit before rolling/coating/baking, but other than that, I pretty much followed the recipe to a T and these were, far and away, the star of Cookie Palooza 2012.  :)

Again, maybe if I had stopped there- on a high note, as it were- then I'd be more apt to label Cookie Palooza 2012 a success. Instead, I continued on to make these Holiday Biscotti with almonds and dried cranberries, dipped in melted white chocolate (which I've made in years past and really like), another bar cookie that I found the recipe for in a book my roommate gave me for my birthday (white chocolate fudge bars from 500 Chocolate Delights: The Only Chocolate Compendium You'll Ever Need by Lauren Floodgate), AND a second batch of the peanut butter blondies with the addition of chocolate chunks. By the time Cookie Palooza 2012 came to an official end on Monday, just the smell of sugar and vanilla was enough to make me nauseous! So now I've got a kitchen full of yummy cookies and no desire to eat any of them... good thing my roommate and co-workers have no such compunctions, eh?